A CSD search for a simple di-fluoroalkene fragment (
Fig. 1) returns 58 fragments from 33 structures.
Fig. 1. The di-fluoroalkene fragment used in the search
Exporting the geometric information from each fragment and analysing them using dSNAP, an initial dendrogram (
Fig. 2a) and 3D plot (
Fig. 2b) are obtained.
Fig. 2a. The dendrogram
Fig. 2b. The 3-dimensional MMDS plot
For
Fig. 2a,
the lower on the similarity scale two fragments (coloured boxes) are
joined by a horizontal tie-bar, the more similar the fragments are.
For
Fig. 2b,
each sphere represents a fragment, and the further apart two points
are, the more different the corresponding fragments are. As a result,
similar samples can be seen to ‘clump’ together into clusters. Very
similar fragments produce tight clusters, whereas less identical ones
give more diffuse groupings. The user is therefore able to tell at a
glance quite a lot about the fragments being grouped together by the
program, and any outliers are easily spotted. The colours are taken
from the dendrogram display, allowing comparison of the results from
the two separate analysis methods.
The initial partitioning
represents the coarse differences of CIS (yellow) and TRANS (red)
versions of the fragment. By further subdividing just the yellow cis
group (
Fig. 3a and
3b), more detailed differences can be observed.
Fig. 3a. The modified dendrogram of Cis fragments only
Fig. 3b. The revised 3-dimensional plot
By
studying example fragments from each of these clusters in Mercury, and
looking at their orientations overlaid in the 3D Fragment Viewer (
Fig. 4),
each of these smaller groups can all be justified as being
different in terms of their chemical structure, as shown in the table
below.
Fig. 4. Selected cis- and trans-fragments overlaid
Colour in Fig. 3a/3b |
Form |
Description |
Number of fragments |
Red |
Trans |
Sterically non-constrained; ideal geometry |
3 |
Yellow |
Trans |
Sterically onstrained |
3 |
Green |
Cis |
All fragments of tetrafluoro-7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane |
21 |
Pale blue |
Cis |
At least one 3-coordinate carbon R-groups generally to an O atom |
8 |
Dark blue |
Cis |
Sterically constrained 7-membered ring |
1 |
Pink |
Cis |
Both R-groups are 4-coordinate |
5 |
Orange (striped) |
Cis |
Resonant C=C bonds with partial double character |
2 |
Yellow green (striped) |
Cis |
Sterically constrained B2 |
2 |
Green (striped) |
Cis |
Mislabelled bonds in the database |
4 |
Blue (striped) |
Cis |
Bridged 6-membered ring |
3 |
Purple (striped) |
Cis |
Bridged 6-membered ring |
1 |
Next four groups |
Cis |
Carbon-cluster |
4 |
Last entry |
Cis |
Part of a cyclobutene ring |
1 |
In this way a detailed level of analysis can be performed in
dSNAP in a minimal amount of time.
Further, more detailed examples can be found in the references linked to on
this page.